|
Robert
Downs |
professor |
USA |
|
Mon
May 2 15:19:49 2005 |
|
Armel Le Bail |
CNRS
Research Director |
France |
|
Mon
May 2 16:37:51 2005 |
|
Alex
Yokochi |
Assistant Professor |
USA |
|
Mon
May 2 18:16:27 2005 |
|
dr h mimi
moon |
mrs |
egypt |
|
Tue
May 3 15:28:08 2005 |
|
Jean-Marc LE MEINS |
Maitre de Conferences |
France |
I have
still a lot of difficulties to understand the "non profit"
definition of the ICDD organisation, above all if I have a look on the
PDF4-Organic 2004. |
Wed
May 4 10:55:36 2005 |
|
L B |
master
student |
France |
|
Wed
May 4 11:23:36 2005 |
|
Dr Fabrice Gaslain |
Post doc |
France |
|
Wed
May 4 11:40:33 2005 |
|
bouhmaida
nouzha |
professor
|
morocco |
this a
very important for africa countries
it's also howpeful to have access to many physical-chemistry journals |
Wed
May 4 17:17:45 2005 |
|
Alan Marc
Schwartz |
Organic
Chemist |
United
States |
Data
collected and analyzed at taxpayer expense has already been purchased. It is purchased again at taxpayer expense
when journals are bought by universities under grant funding, university
overhead levied on grant funding, or though tuition and fees. Gratis basic search plus CIF output and
download is justified to non-abusive users. |
Wed
May 4 18:33:16 2005 |
|
David W.
Glass |
Computer
Programmer |
USA |
I agree. |
Wed
May 4 21:07:25 2005 |
|
EL JAZOULI
Abdelaziz |
Professor
of Chemistry, University Hassan II Mohammedia |
Morocco |
|
Thu
May 5 08:27:12 2005 |
|
Margaret
Piranian |
geologist |
U.S.A. |
|
Thu
May 5 15:22:07 2005 |
|
Alberto
Martnelli |
Researcher |
Itally |
|
Thu
May 5 15:23:33 2005 |
|
Vanessa
Peterson |
Condensed
Matter Physics |
USA |
|
Thu
May 5 15:23:44 2005 |
|
Uwe Kolitsch |
Mineralogist |
Austria |
|
Thu
May 5 15:24:38 2005 |
|
Yaroslav
Mudryk |
Materials
Science |
Ukraine |
|
Thu
May 5 15:24:57 2005 |
|
Igor
Djerdj |
researcher |
Croatia |
|
Thu
May 5 15:25:36 2005 |
|
Nuri
Solak |
Student |
Germany |
|
Thu
May 5 15:27:03 2005 |
|
Patrick
H.J. Mercier |
Postdoctoral
Researcher |
Canada |
|
Thu
May 5 15:28:19 2005 |
|
Markus
Winterer |
Professor
for Nanoparticle Process Technology |
Germany |
|
Thu
May 5 15:29:25 2005 |
|
Guido
Righini |
researcher |
Italy |
|
Thu
May 5 15:30:31 2005 |
|
Simona
Galli |
University
Researcher |
Italy |
|
Thu
May 5 15:31:58 2005 |
|
Mehmet Akkurt |
academic
staff |
Turkey |
|
Thu
May 5 15:33:17 2005 |
|
Alain
BERNARD |
Prof.
Mineralogy/Geochemistry |
Belgium |
|
Thu
May 5 15:34:12 2005 |
|
Davide
Levy |
Resercer |
Italy |
|
Thu
May 5 15:35:26 2005 |
|
Kanani
Lee |
postdoctoral
fellow |
USA |
|
Thu
May 5 15:37:54 2005 |
|
G. Lu |
Scientist |
USA |
It is so
absurd that ICDD copies the mostly publicly published crystallographic data
and sale them at such higher a price. I was even denied to purchase a data
viewer software by ICDD because I refuse to upgrade my year 2000 database. |
Thu
May 5 15:38:59 2005 |
|
Lars Ehm |
Mineralogist |
USA |
|
Thu
May 5 15:39:45 2005 |
|
Habib
BOUGHZALA |
Prof |
Tunisia |
|
Thu
May 5 15:40:28 2005 |
|
Andrew
Putnis |
Professor
of Mineralogy |
Germany |
|
Thu
May 5 15:40:45 2005 |
|
Benali-Cherif Nourredine |
Professor |
Algeria |
En plus des problèmes quotidiens de la recehrche dans nos pays nous sommes confrontés, en cas de préparation de nouveaux composés, à ce problème d'accès aux banques de données pour vérifier, comparer ou faire une recherche bibliographique. En nous privant de cet accès vous nous privez, nous les cristallographes des pays en voie de développement, d'un droit élementaire du savoir. |
Thu
May 5 15:44:52 2005 |
|
Elizabeth
Chavira |
Researcher |
Mexico |
|
Thu
May 5 15:46:56 2005 |
|
Stan Jurecka |
Teacher |
Slovakia |
Thanks to
Mr. A. Le Bail for his activities. |
Thu
May 5 15:47:22 2005 |
|
Lee Penn |
Assistant
Professor of Chemistry |
USA |
|
Thu
May 5 15:49:12 2005 |
|
Dr Hysen
Thomas |
Researcher |
India |
|
Thu
May 5 15:50:48 2005 |
|
Namsoo Shin |
Staff
Scientist |
Republic
of Korea |
|
Thu
May 5 15:51:36 2005 |
|
José
Marcos Sasaki |
Professor |
Brazil |
|
Thu
May 5 15:52:40 2005 |
|
Marco E.
Ciriotti |
retired |
Italy |
|
Thu
May 5 15:53:19 2005 |
|
Ferdinando
Costantino |
Research
Fellow |
Italy |
|
Thu
May 5 15:56:21 2005 |
|
Raimundo Lora Serrano |
Physicist.
PhD student |
Brazil |
|
Thu
May 5 15:56:25 2005 |
|
John
Matthais O Callaghan |
Ph.D |
Ireland |
|
Thu
May 5 16:03:40 2005 |
|
Xianqin Wang |
Ph.D |
USA |
|
Thu
May 5 16:04:02 2005 |
|
Dana T.
Griffen |
Professor
of Geology |
USA |
|
Thu
May 5 16:08:55 2005 |
|
Stuart Miller |
phd student |
uk |
|
Thu
May 5 16:09:01 2005 |
|
Piero
Macchi |
researcher |
Italy |
|
Thu
May 5 16:10:41 2005 |
|
Casati Nicola Pietro |
PhD
student |
Italy |
|
Thu
May 5 16:10:46 2005 |
|
Udo
Becker |
Associate
Professor of Earth Materials |
USA |
We are
doing a lot of molecular simulations on all kinds of minerals and access to
crystallography structure data bases is crucial for our work. |
Thu
May 5 16:11:11 2005 |
|
Hakan
Gaşan |
Research
Asistant |
Turkey |
|
Thu
May 5 16:16:06 2005 |
|
Xim Bokhimi |
Scientist |
Mexico |
|
Thu
May 5 16:16:38 2005 |
|
Miguel
Gregorkiewitz |
prof |
Italy |
|
Thu
May 5 16:24:34 2005 |
|
Roberta
Oberti |
researcher |
Italy |
|
Thu
May 5 16:30:20 2005 |
|
Weisbecker
Patrick |
Research
engineer |
FRANCE |
|
Thu
May 5 16:30:55 2005 |
|
Kim Witt |
Chemist |
United
States |
|
Thu
May 5 16:33:21 2005 |
|
William
M. Shannon |
Geochemist |
USA |
|
Thu
May 5 16:37:44 2005 |
|
Pamela
Burnley |
Geology
Faculty |
United
States |
|
Thu
May 5 16:38:58 2005 |
|
Dave
Barthelmy |
Senior
Consultant |
USA |
As the
author of webmineral.com, any public access to mineral data promotes and
encourages further understanding of the mineral (material) sciences. |
Thu
May 5 16:39:26 2005 |
|
Angela
Maria de Lemos Medeiros |
Mechanical
Engineer |
Brazil |
|
Thu
May 5 16:39:30 2005 |
|
John H.
Dooley |
Geochemist |
United
States |
|
Thu
May 5 16:42:31 2005 |
|
Mirko
Schoenitz |
Research
Professor |
USA |
|
Thu
May 5 16:47:00 2005 |
|
Aldo de
Almeida Oliveira |
Civil
Engineer |
Brazil |
|
Thu
May 5 16:51:10 2005 |
|
Fabiane Alexsandra Andrade de Jesus |
Student |
Brazil |
|
Thu
May 5 16:57:37 2005 |
|
Dr. Karel
Saksl |
scientist |
Germany |
|
Thu
May 5 17:01:01 2005 |
|
Eleonora
Aneggi |
PhD
student |
Italy |
|
Thu
May 5 17:01:48 2005 |
|
Nivaldo
Lúcio Speziali |
Physicist |
Brazil |
The
information on data basis is generated by persons who, in same cases, have to
pay for obtaining it. It is not reasonable; it should be freely available! |
Thu
May 5 17:05:42 2005 |
|
Yaroslav
Filinchuk |
chemist-crystallographer |
Switzerland |
|
Thu
May 5 17:21:47 2005 |
|
Clayton
Frank Gardinier |
Senior
Scientist |
USA |
|
Thu
May 5 17:23:14 2005 |
|
Sean
Cadogan |
Professor |
Australia |
|
Thu
May 5 17:25:09 2005 |
|
Martin
Kunz |
Research
Associate |
USA |
|
Thu
May 5 17:31:01 2005 |
|
vengadesh
kumara mangalam |
Research
student |
India |
|
Thu
May 5 17:34:22 2005 |
|
Claudio
Perottoni |
Professor |
Brazil |
|
Thu
May 5 17:36:23 2005 |
|
Daniela
Kovacheva |
Scientific
researcher |
Bulgaria |
|
Thu
May 5 17:43:47 2005 |
|
Ludwig
Keller |
scientist/industry |
US |
|
Thu
May 5 17:45:31 2005 |
|
George
Rossman |
Mineralogy |
USA |
|
Thu
May 5 17:59:16 2005 |
|
tiago
silva rodrigues |
student |
brazil |
I need
this !!!! |
Thu
May 5 18:09:57 2005 |
|
Genivaldo
Julio Perpetuo |
Adjunct
III |
Brazil |
|
Thu
May 5 18:11:21 2005 |
|
maria
regileuda morais monteiro |
student |
brazil |
|
Thu
May 5 18:21:40 2005 |
|
José
Osman dos Santos |
researcher |
Brazil |
|
Thu
May 5 18:22:36 2005 |
|
Mehmet Cetinkol |
Grad Student |
USA |
|
Thu
May 5 18:29:09 2005 |
|
Raquel Argonz |
Researcher |
Brasil |
|
Thu
May 5 18:34:33 2005 |
|
Viviane Carillo Ferrari |
Pos doctoral |
Brazil |
|
Thu
May 5 18:55:22 2005 |
|
Isolda Maria de Castro Mendes |
Teacher |
Brazil |
|
Thu
May 5 19:03:21 2005 |
|
Cora Lind |
Assistant
Professor in Chemistry |
USA |
|
Thu
May 5 19:12:09 2005 |
|
Caroline
Blackshields |
PHD
Student |
Eire |
|
Thu
May 5 19:16:46 2005 |
|
Alexandre S. Anastacio |
PhD
Studente |
Brazil |
|
Thu
May 5 19:24:59 2005 |
|
Amina
Aouad |
Post Doc |
Morroco |
|
Thu
May 5 19:26:27 2005 |
|
James B.
Harsh |
Professor
of Soil Science |
USA |
Because I
am only an occasional user of crystallographic databases (for example, during
the mineralogy section of my soil chemistry course) I cannot justify paying
full price for access to a database. I generally just use crystal structures
that are prepackaged with CrystalMaker. Open access would allow my students
and I to learn to use the crystallography software for a large variety of
soil minerals. |
Thu
May 5 19:36:21 2005 |
|
Alexander
Smirnov |
PhD student |
Slovakia |
|
Thu
May 5 19:43:11 2005 |
|
Angelo
Malachias de Souza |
Physicist |
Brazil |
|
Thu
May 5 19:47:40 2005 |
|
Apolinar
Ramirez Saldivar |
Physicist |
México |
No
comments |
Thu
May 5 20:01:40 2005 |
|
Bartolomeu
Cruz Viana Neto |
Physicist |
Brazil |
|
Thu
May 5 20:02:34 2005 |
|
Anthony R.
Kampf |
Curator
of Mineral Sciences |
USA |
|
Thu May 5 20:12:23 2005 |
|
Tom
Trainor |
Assistant
Professor |
USA |
|
Thu
May 5 20:23:43 2005 |
|
Luca
Farina |
Technician |
Italy |
|
Thu
May 5 20:36:49 2005 |
|
Rommel Bezerra
Viana |
Graduate
Student |
Brazil |
|
Thu
May 5 20:54:24 2005 |
|
Jose
Fernando Q. Rey |
physicist |
Brazil |
|
Thu May 5 20:55:00 2005 |
|
Rodrigo Freitas
Guimarães |
Engineer |
Brazil |
|
Thu
May 5 21:15:47 2005 |
|
S. Garcia-Granda |
Professor
of Physical Chemistry |
Spain |
|
Thu
May 5 21:30:47 2005 |
|
Douglas R.
Allen |
Mineralogist |
United
States |
|
Thu
May 5 21:36:58 2005 |
|
Laurence
Philip Aldridge |
Retired |
Australia |
|
Thu
May 5 21:37:07 2005 |
|
Dan
Stasko |
Professor,
Chemistry |
USA |
|
Thu
May 5 21:40:41 2005 |
|
Ronaldo Santos
da Silva |
student |
Brazil |
|
Thu
May 5 22:13:36 2005 |
|
Cristiano Teles de Meneses |
PhD student |
Brazil |
|
Thu
May 5 22:43:53 2005 |
|
Pannee
burckel |
Chemist |
USA |
|
Thu
May 5 22:58:11 2005 |
|
Renato
Bastos Guimarães |
Physics |
Brazil |
|
Thu
May 5 23:02:52 2005 |
|
Ozhan
Unverdi |
Research
Student |
UK |
|
Thu
May 5 23:27:01 2005 |
|
Robert R.
Reeber, PhD |
Materials
Science, Adjunct Professor |
USA |
The data is
all obtained by the scientific community and should be available without
charge. As a fact of nature it should not be copywritable. |
Thu
May 5 23:39:33 2005 |
|
John
Winston Abitibol Menezes |
Mechanical
Engenieer |
Brazil |
|
Thu
May 5 23:40:12 2005 |
|
Maria
Helena Sousa Soares de Oliveira Braga |
Assistant
Professor in Physics |
Portugal |
|
Thu
May 5 23:42:38 2005 |
|
Bráulio
Soares Archanjo |
Physicist |
Brazil |
|
Thu
May 5 23:55:51 2005 |
|
Liz
Goodall |
Powder
X-ray Diffraction |
Australia |
|
Fri
May 6 00:51:39 2005 |
|
vahit
atakan |
graduate
asistant |
usa |
|
Fri May 6 00:54:38 2005 |
|
André de Oliveira Girão Maia |
teacher |
Brasil |
Informations
free !!! NOW !!! |
Fri
May 6 01:59:15 2005 |
|
Elsa
Sileo |
Chemist |
Argentina |
|
Fri
May 6 02:11:45 2005 |
|
Eduardo
Sidney Nunes dos Santos |
Student |
Bazil |
|
Fri May 6 02:19:55 2005 |
|
Helio
Salim de Amorim |
Professor |
Brazil |
|
Fri
May 6 02:49:29 2005 |
|
Angel
Bustamante Dominguez |
Physics |
Peru |
We need
this information |
Fri
May 6 03:26:54 2005 |
|
Lilian
Pantoja Sosman |
Physicist |
Brazil |
|
Fri
May 6 03:59:50 2005 |
|
Andres R R Papa |
Physicist |
Brazil |
|
Fri
May 6 04:00:59 2005 |
|
Tay Yee
Yan |
Postgraduate |
Singapore |
|
Fri
May 6 04:47:03 2005 |
|
Athinarayanan
SUNDARESAN |
Assistant
Professor |
India |
It is a
great idea and very much helpful. |
Fri May 6 05:32:07 2005 |
|
Karsten Winter |
PhD
Student |
Australia |
I am a
Crystallographer and our University is suffering from a constant lack of
funding - so the databases are not being updated and are also not easily
available |
Fri
May 6 07:30:10 2005 |
|
Peter
Paufler |
University
Professor |
Germany |
|
Fri
May 6 07:59:30 2005 |
|
GIOVANNI
FERRARIS |
PROFESSOR |
ITALY |
|
Fri
May 6 08:51:50 2005 |
|
Frederic
Hatert |
Researcher |
Belgium |
|
Fri
May 6 09:05:35 2005 |
|
Florian
Heidelbach |
Geologist |
Germany |
|
Fri
May 6 09:08:44 2005 |
|
Leonid A.
Solovyov |
researcher |
Russia |
|
Fri
May 6 09:28:35 2005 |
|
Chandan Mazumdar |
Scientist |
India |
This is
really a good proposal for people from developing countries. |
Fri
May 6 09:33:16 2005 |
|
Devidas
Gulwade |
Research
scholar |
India |
|
Fri
May 6 09:55:35 2005 |
|
Bruno
Dacuña Mariño |
Assistant
researcher |
Spain |
|
Fri May 6 10:03:34 2005 |
|
Fernando
Scordari |
Full
Professor |
Italy |
|
Fri May 6 10:13:06 2005 |
|
guilhem DEZANNEAU |
chercheur |
France |
|
Fri
May 6 10:18:06 2005 |
|
Patrizia
Imperatori |
researcher |
Italy |
|
Fri
May 6 11:06:07 2005 |
|
Talaat
Meaz |
lecturer
of physics |
Egypt |
|
Fri May 6 11:12:18 2005 |
|
William
Edryd Stephens |
Geologist
in University |
UK |
|
Fri
May 6 11:35:20 2005 |
|
GOMEZ DE
LA TORRE, MARIA |
CHEMIST |
SPAIN |
|
Fri
May 6 12:01:54 2005 |
|
Giorgio
Marinoni |
PhD
student |
Italia |
I trust
there should be no economical barriers to knowledge, and databases are
essential tools for the scientific community and should be accessibile to
everyone. |
Fri
May 6 12:32:17 2005 |
|
Maximo
Ferreira da Silveira |
Physics |
Brazil |
|
Fri
May 6 12:45:18 2005 |
|
Carlos
Marcio Soares Rocha |
Mestrando
em Geologia |
Brasil |
|
Fri
May 6 12:51:33 2005 |
|
Amit
Sinha |
Scientist |
India |
|
Fri
May 6 14:25:22 2005 |
|
igor de abreu e
lima |
senior
lecturer |
brazil |
|
Fri
May 6 14:34:04 2005 |
|
Ricardo
Borges Barthem |
Professor |
Brazil |
|
Fri
May 6 14:40:12 2005 |
|
vegner
hizau dos santos utuni |
chemistry |
brazil |
|
Fri
May 6 14:46:22 2005 |
|
Julio
Cesar Guimarães Tedesco |
Teacher |
Brazil |
|
Fri
May 6 14:56:41 2005 |
|
Fernando
Cezar Araujo Gonçalves |
Professor |
Brazil |
|
Fri
May 6 15:20:09 2005 |
|
Tonci
Balic-Zunic |
Associate
Professor, University |
Denmark |
|
Fri May 6 15:21:57 2005 |
|
Juergen
Glinnemann |
Mineralogist |
Germany |
|
Fri
May 6 15:30:58 2005 |
|
Enrico
Mattievich |
Prof. of
Pysics |
Brazil |
|
Fri
May 6 15:48:08 2005 |
|
Paula Brito |
Estudante |
Brasil |
|
Fri
May 6 15:57:43 2005 |
|
Raul José
da Silva Camara Mauricio da Fonseca |
Professor |
Brazil |
This a
good initiative for all scientists that works in materials science and
corelated areas. |
Fri May 6 16:27:29 2005 |
|
Mireille Krier |
Ph.D. Student |
FRANCE |
|
Fri
May 6 16:28:30 2005 |
|
Ivan
Tubert-Brohman |
Chemist |
USA |
|
Fri
May 6 17:06:55 2005 |
|
Dr. Salim
Bouaricha |
Research
Officer |
Canada |
|
Fri
May 6 17:10:59 2005 |
|
Krassimir
Bozhilov |
Scinetist |
USA |
|
Fri
May 6 17:11:10 2005 |
|
Robert D
Skala |
Research
Scientist |
USA |
|
Fri
May 6 17:11:55 2005 |
|
Marco
Sommariva |
PhD
Student |
Italy |
|
Fri
May 6 17:43:44 2005 |
|
SEBAIS Miloud |
Professeur |
Algerie |
|
Fri May 6 17:54:19 2005 |
|
Dr. Eric Siebel |
Chemist |
Germany |
|
Fri
May 6 18:31:20 2005 |
|
M. SAADI |
professeur |
maroc |
|
Fri
May 6 18:47:07 2005 |
|
MOUSSER Abdelhamid |
PROFESSEUR |
CONSTANTINE-ALGERIE |
|
Fri May 6 18:54:00 2005 |
|
Helio Henrique Barbosa Rocha |
Chemical
Engineer |
Brazil |
|
Fri
May 6 18:59:51 2005 |
|
Ahmed
Ahmed Ramadan |
Professor
of Materials Physics |
Egypt |
|
Fri
May 6 19:20:50 2005 |
|
Holger Koenig |
Chemist |
Germany |
|
Fri
May 6 20:35:08 2005 |
|
Marcelo Antonio Santos da Silva |
professor |
Brazil |
|
Fri May 6 20:40:13 2005 |
|
Ali BOULTIF |
Enseignant - Chercheur |
Algérie |
Merci infiniment pour une si bénéfique initiative. |
Fri
May 6 20:50:14 2005 |
|
Ihab A.
Abdel-Latif |
Lecturer |
Egypt |
|
Fri
May 6 21:15:13 2005 |
|
Mylene
Ribeiro Moura |
Estudant |
Brazil |
|
Fri
May 6 22:07:43 2005 |
|
Karimat
EL-Sayed |
Professor
at Ain _Shams University |
Egypt |
Egypt is
a devoloping Country and We canot have the regular Crystallographic data base
which we realy need it in our work accordingly if the crystallographic community
allow us to have it on line it will be a big achievement for the third world
countries |
Fri
May 6 22:59:08 2005 |
|
Glenn
Alfred Waychunas |
Staff
Scientist |
USA |
|
Sat
May 7 01:25:55 2005 |
|
José
Alberto P. Bonapace |
Associate
Professor |
Brazil |
|
Sat
May 7 02:51:37 2005 |
|
Colin
H.L. Kennard |
Crystallographer |
Australia |
|
Sat
May 7 06:01:20 2005 |
|
Ricardo
Bento |
Teacher |
Brazil |
|
Sat
May 7 08:03:45 2005 |
|
OUHENIA Salim |
Post
Graduate student |
Algeria |
|
Sat
May 7 12:31:58 2005 |
|
Madani
Samah |
Teacher |
Algeria |
|
Sat
May 7 12:51:06 2005 |
|
guergouri mounia |
enseignant-chercheur |
algeria |
|
Sat
May 7 13:03:44 2005 |
|
Samy Taha Nasser |
Lectural |
Egypt |
|
Sat
May 7 13:55:03 2005 |
|
PHAM Quoc Nghi |
Ph.D student |
France |
|
Sat
May 7 14:10:15 2005 |
|
Roland
Boese |
Professor |
Germany |
The data
gained with public money cannot be transferred into private property! |
Sat
May 7 14:32:40 2005 |
|
Jacob
Zabicky |
Chemist
& Chemical Engineer |
Israel |
|
Sat May 7 14:53:28 2005 |
|
Temistocles
Luz |
PhD
Student |
Brazil |
|
Sat
May 7 15:15:46 2005 |
|
Mohammed
MANSORI |
Professor |
Morocco |
|
Sat
May 7 15:30:42 2005 |
|
Brajendra
Singh |
Research
Scholar |
INDIA |
|
Sat
May 7 16:40:18 2005 |
|
José Celestino de Barros Neto |
PhD Student |
Brazil |
|
Sat May 7 17:06:23 2005 |
|
Helmut
Ehrenberg |
Physicist |
Germany |
|
Sat
May 7 17:18:34 2005 |
|
Thanasis
Gimisis |
Chemist |
Greece |
|
Sat
May 7 22:14:14 2005 |
|
Labarre
Jean |
University
Teacher |
France |
|
Sat
May 7 22:35:02 2005 |
|
Mwaffak
RUKIAH |
Crystallographer |
Syria |
|
Sat
May 7 22:54:24 2005 |
|
Giora Kimmel |
Professor |
Israel |
|
Sun May 8 06:07:08 2005 |
|
Russel Brent |
Stone
seller |
RSA |
N/a |
Sun
May 8 07:35:35 2005 |
|
Amor
HADDAD |
Professor |
Tunisia |
|
Sun
May 8 08:06:17 2005 |
|
bouacida
sofiane |
Searcher-teacher |
Algeria |
|
Sun
May 8 11:58:52 2005 |
|
Stengl
Vaclac |
chemst |
czech
republic |
|
Sun
May 8 13:21:51 2005 |
|
Jan
Panteltje |
designer |
netherlands |
|
Sun
May 8 13:49:11 2005 |
|
Petrucio
Barrozo da Silva |
doctor
study |
Brasil |
|
Sun
May 8 14:37:00 2005 |
|
hamdane
hamid |
researcher |
uea |
|
Sun
May 8 14:38:41 2005 |
|
Dr.Ibrahim Odeh |
University
Faculty |
Jordan |
|
Sun
May 8 14:46:14 2005 |
|
Djedouani Amel |
assistante maitre |
Algeria |
|
Sun
May 8 15:13:18 2005 |
|
Adailson
Souza |
Mechanical
Engineer |
Brazil |
|
Sun
May 8 16:32:54 2005 |
|
Evagelia
moshopoulou |
research
staff scientist |
Greece |
|
Sun
May 8 18:18:24 2005 |
|
SVAB, Erzsebet |
physicist |
Hungary |
|
Sun
May 8 18:42:11 2005 |
|
Susana de Souza Barros |
physicist |
Brasil |
|
Sun
May 8 19:31:37 2005 |
|
Amar
Benmoussa |
Professor,
University of Annaba |
Algeria |
|
Sun
May 8 19:37:15 2005 |
|
Artem R.
Oganov |
Senior
Research Scientist and Lecturer |
Switzerland |
|
Sun
May 8 21:38:26 2005 |
|
Shamus
Husheer |
PhD Student |
United
Kingdom |
I am a
student of crystallography at Cambridge University, and find that much of my
research relies on the use of these types of databases. Clearly, my department would therefore
subscribe to them. However, in order
to check my work, reviewers also need a subscription at present - which is
not provided (to my knowledge) by the journals that expect them to perform
the review. The petition seems to
provide a reasonable solution to this problem. |
Sun
May 8 22:23:34 2005 |
|
KAORI
CHIBA-KAMOSHIDA |
biophysics |
Japan |
|
Mon
May 9 01:41:19 2005 |
|
Brendan
Sinnamon |
Librarian |
Australia |
|
Mon
May 9 01:49:27 2005 |
|
Radhakrishnan
Chitra |
Scientist |
India |
|
Mon
May 9 05:22:37 2005 |
|
J K
Dattagupta |
Research |
India |
|
Mon May 9 06:51:23 2005 |
|
Johan de Villiers |
Professor |
South
Africa |
I support
this wholeheartedly. Especially users of the databases in the developing
countries often cannot afford them. |
Mon
May 9 07:28:29 2005 |
|
Peter
Moeck |
Prof. of
Physics |
USA |
|
Mon May 9 07:30:18 2005 |
|
Dr. Melanie
Rademeyer |
Academic |
South
Africa |
As a
result of our poor exchange rate, researchers in South Africa have to pay a
very high price to obtain these databases. As a young academic and
researcher, I could not afford the CSD in the first two years of my career,
which made crystallographic research very difficult. Even now, obtaining the
CSD is extremely expensive, and a large percentage of my research funds is
used for this. |
Mon
May 9 07:38:04 2005 |
|
Apurba
Kanti Deb |
Research
Fellow |
India |
This
would help the Crystallographic community a lot. |
Mon May 9 07:52:29 2005 |
|
Esna du Plessis |
PhD
student |
South
Africa |
|
Mon
May 9 08:03:04 2005 |
|
Sebastian
A. Cirkel |
Chemistry
Student |
Germany |
|
Mon
May 9 08:29:02 2005 |
|
Orde Q.
Munro |
Associate
Professor of Chemistry |
South
Africa |
Due to a
poor exchange rate and non-competitive research grants, we suffer as a
developing country from access to software like the CSD etc. I scrape together the finances to afford 2
licences to the CSD each year, but this means that most people in our School
have no access to the database. I
would like to see open access so that we can use the CSD more in
undergraduate teaching and more widely in research, e.g. not just
crystallography, but all disciplines.
I like the PDB for this very reason - no charge for PDB files from the
database. |
Mon
May 9 08:32:49 2005 |
|
Nevenka
Rajic |
Professor |
Serbia&Montenegro |
|
Mon
May 9 08:42:16 2005 |
|
Jose
Montejo Bernardo |
Student |
Spain |
|
Mon
May 9 08:53:28 2005 |
|
Jaromir
MAREK |
assoc.
prof. at Masaryk University in Brno |
Czech
Republic |
|
Mon May 9 08:55:31 2005 |
|
Rajesh G.
Gonnade |
Crystallographer |
India |
|
Mon
May 9 08:59:09 2005 |
|
Maja Mrak |
Dr |
Slovenia |
|
Mon
May 9 09:20:22 2005 |
|
Daniela
Pinto |
Post-doc |
Italy |
|
Mon
May 9 09:24:12 2005 |
|
P. Durand |
postdoc |
germany |
|
Mon
May 9 09:29:47 2005 |
|
Marian
Surowiec |
Professor
in material science |
Poland |
|
Mon
May 9 09:34:56 2005 |
|
jelsch
christian |
researcher |
france |
|
Mon
May 9 10:15:51 2005 |
|
le guen stephanie |
postdoc |
france |
|
Mon May 9 10:17:15 2005 |
|
Legein Christophe |
Maître de conférence |
France |
|
Mon May 9 10:22:38 2005 |
|
Ludwik
Dobrzynski |
Physicist |
Poland |
|
Mon
May 9 10:25:21 2005 |
|
Zdirad
Zak |
professor |
Czech
Republic |
|
Mon
May 9 10:37:54 2005 |
|
Abdellah
Ziadi |
researcher |
Morocco |
|
Mon
May 9 10:42:07 2005 |
|
COURBION
georges |
University
Professor |
France |
|
Mon May 9 10:47:37 2005 |
|
Dejan
Poleti |
Professor,
Fac. of Technology and Metallurgy |
Serbia |
|
Mon
May 9 10:51:31 2005 |
|
Markus
Pohlmann |
Mineralogist |
Germany |
|
Mon
May 9 10:57:35 2005 |
|
Harry
Wondergem |
X-Ray
Diffraction Specialist |
Netherlands |
|
Mon
May 9 10:59:38 2005 |
|
Wlodzimierz
Keller |
physicist |
Brasil |
I am most
strongly for this petition |
Mon
May 9 11:01:21 2005 |
|
chateigner
daniel |
professor |
France |
|
Mon
May 9 11:06:28 2005 |
|
Tomasz
Wojtowicz |
researcher |
Poland |
|
Mon May 9 11:11:44 2005 |
|
Claude Depollier |
Professor |
France |
|
Mon May 9 11:15:25 2005 |
|
MARIE Philippe |
Searcher |
FRANCE |
|
Mon
May 9 11:20:03 2005 |
|
Francis
Studer |
CNRS
Searcher |
France |
|
Mon
May 9 11:20:08 2005 |
|
Polidori
Giampiero |
researcher |
Italy |
|
Mon
May 9 11:27:11 2005 |
|
Jan K. Maurin |
senior
researcher, crystallography |
Poland |
Although
I personaly and most of my colegues crystallographers in Poland have access
to the CSD database, it is completely unavailable for other groups of
researchers. To make the data available in even very limited form is very
important for all of us. |
Mon
May 9 11:32:12 2005 |
|
BEN YAHIA
HAMDI |
PHD Student |
France |
|
Mon May 9 11:38:46 2005 |
|
Michael Nippus |
Physicist |
Germany |
|
Mon
May 9 11:44:10 2005 |
|
David
Breard |
PhD
student |
France |
|
Mon May 9 11:49:32 2005 |
|
Denis
Pelloquin |
CNRS
researcher |
France |
|
Mon
May 9 11:50:19 2005 |
|
JOSIEN
Ludovic |
Ingenieer
|
FRANCE |
|
Mon
May 9 12:10:56 2005 |
|
Saulius
Grazulis |
crystallographer |
Lithuania |
De facto
unavailability of small molecule xray data that has been published is indeed
an obstacle for research, education, and is morally wrong. We often end up in
absurd situation when coordinates for small molecules have to be taken from
the Protein Data Bank entries! I have
had an idea to organise a wiki-style, comunity edited and peer-reviewed
database where all wolontiers who have access to printed versions of the
crystallographic and other structural papers key in coordinates and share
them on the Web under some kind of Creative Commons
(http://creativecommons.org/) license. I am very pleased to see that you are
starting virtually tha same ide under http://www.crystallography.net/ :) I am glad that I am not alone with the
opinion that published data should be available to everybody, at no licensing
costs or usability restrictions. If CSD and other organisations refuse to
open publicly available data, the scientific community will have to put an
extra effort and build the databases once more. Sincerely, Dr. Saulius Grazulis |
Mon May 9 12:20:12 2005 |
|
Jean-Paul Jernot |
chercheur |
France |
|
Mon May 9 12:23:32 2005 |
|
anne
Spasojevic |
associate
professor |
France |
|
Mon
May 9 12:23:33 2005 |
|
Dr.
Hassan Hammud |
Assoc.
Prof. Chemistry Beirut Arb University |
Lebanon |
|
Mon
May 9 12:51:08 2005 |
|
BENGUEDOUAR
LAMIA |
LECTURER |
ALGERIA |
|
Mon
May 9 12:52:16 2005 |
|
Prof.
Bojan Šoptrajanov |
Academician |
Republic
of Macedonia |
|
Mon
May 9 12:53:07 2005 |
|
Gabor
Oszlanyi |
physicist |
Hungary |
|
Mon
May 9 12:54:44 2005 |
|
Benjamin
Bouvier |
Researcher |
Germany |
|
Mon
May 9 12:57:17 2005 |
|
BENGUEDOUAR
LAMIA |
lecturer |
ALGERIA |
|
Mon
May 9 12:57:31 2005 |
|
Gyula
Faigel |
physicist |
Hungary |
|
Mon
May 9 12:58:51 2005 |
|
Gabor
Bortel |
physicist |
Hungary |
|
Mon
May 9 12:59:50 2005 |
|
Miklos
Tegze |
physicist |
Hungary |
|
Mon
May 9 12:59:57 2005 |
|
Tamas
Pusztai |
physicist |
Hungary |
|
Mon
May 9 13:00:21 2005 |
|
Sandor
Pekker |
chemist |
Hungary |
|
Mon
May 9 13:02:54 2005 |
|
Henni Ouerdane |
temporary lecturer |
France |
|
Mon
May 9 13:15:51 2005 |
|
Aleksandar
Kremenovic |
Professor |
Serbia
and Montenegro |
|
Mon
May 9 13:24:09 2005 |
|
Comenge
Yannick |
Jeune chercheur précaire |
FRANCE |
|
Mon May 9 13:25:34 2005 |
|
Ricardo
Faccio |
PhD.
Student (Chemistry and Materials) |
Uruguay |
|
Mon
May 9 13:32:49 2005 |
|
Reinier Kaptein |
Student |
France |
|
Mon
May 9 13:47:40 2005 |
|
Gligor
Jovanovski |
Professor |
Republic
of Macedonia |
|
Mon May 9 14:10:35 2005 |
|
josé Flávio tenório de Oliveira |
professor |
brasil |
|
Mon May 9 14:29:43 2005 |
|
Jacques Darriet |
Directeur de Recherche CNRS |
France |
|
Mon May 9 14:35:48 2005 |
|
Thomas
Kerestedjian |
Mineralogist |
Bulgaria |
|